Independent - Supporters shout down QPR-Wimbledon merger
By Steve Tongue
Friday, 4 May 2001
Queen's Park Rangers and Wimbledon have effectively admitted defeat for
a proposal to merge after furious opposition from supporters. But the
plan will not be the last such attempt at combining clubs or grounds in
London's saturated football market.
Queen's Park Rangers and
Wimbledon have effectively admitted defeat for a proposal to merge after
furious opposition from supporters. But the plan will not be the last
such attempt at combining clubs or grounds in London's saturated
football market.
The two struggling First Division clubs � QPR
will be relegated after Sunday's final match of the season � sounded out
the Football League yesterday, but had to back-track once the news was
leaked, to a predictably hostile reaction. Wimbledon's chairman, Charles
Koppel, said: "We have been approached by QPR and, while discussions
about a possible merger have taken place, we realise that no agreement
could ever be reached without consulting our supporters first."
Loftus
Road plc, the parent company which owns Rangers, said: "It is not
helpful that the news has been leaked as we were intent on exploring the
opportunity in a sensible and controlled manner. The talks will only
continue if there is approval from our supporter base."
It
quickly became evident that no such support would be forthcoming from
the fans of either club. The Wimbledon Independent Supporters'
Association declared: "We unequivocally oppose the merger of two
separate identities, families, supporters and histories. We urge the
vigilance of Wimbledon and QPR supporters and ask that you make your
voices heard far and wide."
Libby Magrill, speaking for QPR 1st,
the recently established supporters' trust, said: "Any move to merge QPR
with Wimbledon will be opposed by every possible means. QPR fans will
fight to retain the identity of our club. We will be seeking a clear
statement from the Football League on this latest development. If they
sanction the merger, what next? It could open the floodgates and kill
off many of our clubs."
The League confirmed that its executive
board had been informed of the proposal and added: "Whilst they will
give favourable consideration to any proposal, they must also bear in
mind the implications for the league competition and for the supporters
of both clubs."
The clubs appeared keen to push the plan through
in time for next season if possible. A merged club would have to take
its place in the lower division of the two � the Second Division � which
would present complications concerning promotion and relegation,
including the question of whether any team went down from the Nationwide
League to the Conference.
Just as Reading and Oxford United
supporters did when Robert Maxwell wanted to create "Thames Valley
Royals", followers of both clubs have resisted similar plans in the
past, with Rangers normally the predators. In 1967 they tried to take
over Brentford and move to Griffin Park; the move was defeated when
Brentford's chairman, Jack Dunnett, sold his controlling interest to a
syndicate of supporters. Twenty years later QPR proposed merging with
Fulham, whose supporters were also able to help save their club and
ground, backing Jimmy Hill as the new chairman.
Wimbledon fans
have learnt to live with uncertainty almost from the time they became a
League club in 1977. Their then-chairman, Ron Noades, wanted to merge
them with Crystal Palace, but ended up selling the club to Sam Hammam
and buying Palace instead. He was eventually able to lure Wimbledon to
Selhurst Park as Palace's tenants, where they remain, Hammam's sale of
the club to Norwegian owners having done nothing to end speculation
about relocating anywhere from Milton Keynes to Dublin.
Noades
has moved on to become chairman of his third London club, Brentford. He
insisted yesterday that he was not involved in the new plans, but
admitted he would be interested in ground-sharing if Brentford are able
to build a new stadium in Feltham. He has also talked to QPR about
sharing Loftus Road.
It would hardly be surprising if Noades
became a principal figure in any future developments. He has always
cherished the idea of building one major South London club to challenge
Arsenal and Tottenham, but, having failed to make Palace the core of it,
he sold up, at a huge profit, while keeping the freehold of their
Selhurst Park ground.
GUARDIAN Guardian/Martin Thorpe - May 4, 2001
Fans rebel as London clubs talk of merger
Wimbledon
and Queens Park Rangers moved last night to defuse fan fury by pledging
that a proposed merger of the clubs would not go ahead if supporters
strongly object to the controversial plan.
The two London clubs
admitted they have held talks about a merger as a way to overcome their
problems: Wimbledon of the First Division have no ground and a small fan
base while QPR, just relegated to the Second, are in administration
with debts of �8m.
The plan was even discussed at a meeting of
the Football League board, who gave it a provisional green light though
they had not received any concrete submission from either club.
But supporter reaction was immediately hostile, with protests planned and vows made to "fight any merger to the end".
Although
QPR initially approached Wimbledon with the plan, the Dons chairman
Charles Koppel summed up their joint thinking when he said yesterday:
"Both clubs have a unique set of problems and we have to ask, is there a
way to resolve those problems? Are we stronger together than apart?
"We
are committed to exploring all available options for strengthening the
club on and off the pitch. Our initial view is that, in the current
financial environment for football outside the Premier League, the idea
could have merit and may be worth exploring further."
Both clubs had been hoping to persuade their fans of the practical and financial merits of a merger.
Despite
30 declarations of interest in buying out the current QPR owner Chris
Wright, no firm offer has come in, even from a City consortium who came
to light yesterday and are allegedly considering a �12m takeover.
The
plan would see a new club emerge called Wimbledon and Queens Park
Rangers - other names floated yesterday included Queens Park Dons and
Wimbledon Rangers - playing at Loftus Road in the Second Division,
depending on league approval.
Wimbledon's Terry Burton would be manager of the new club and the shirt colours would reflect those of both teams.
The
two clubs set out on talks hoping the climate of supporter obstruction
which saw stillbirths for two previous proposed mergers -Fulham Park
Rangers and Thames Valley Royals (Reading and Oxford) - had changed.
They also felt it would be easier in the case of teams that did not have
a historic rivalry.
QPR, though accepting they would lose some
fans, had even estimated that the new team would attract between 10,000
and 12,000 for the first game next season.
But the leak to a
national newspaper caught both clubs by surprise and dented hopes of
persuading fans of the financial and practical advantages. There was
some suspicion that this was the motive behind the leak.
Libby
Magrill, a spokeswoman for QPR 1st, the QPR Supporters Trust, insisted:
"QPR fans will fight to retain the identity of our club. Any move to
merge QPR with Wimbledon this year, or at any stage in the future, will
be opposed by every possible means."
The Wimbledon Independent
Supporters' Association declared that they "unequivocally oppose the
merger of two separate identities, families, supporters and histories".
Wisa
and QPR 1st plan to lobby the league while a protest by Wimbledon fans
is scheduled for the final game, at home to Norwich on Sunday. At QPR
supporters demonstrated outside Loftus Road yesterday.
QPR
quickly issued a statement criticising the leak and insisted that before
any final decision they had always intended to consult their
supporters, via a questionnaire, in a "sensible and controlled manner",
and will do so still if merger discussions continue.
Privately
QPR went further. "It had always been decided this wouldn't go through
without the blessing of the majority of the fans," insisted one source.
"It just wouldn't have worked."
Koppel took a similar line. "It has to come down to whether or not the supporters feel that it is something they can buy into."
Guardian
QPR and Wimbledon in merger talks Scott Murray guardian.co.uk, Thursday 3 May 2001
Queens
Park Rangers have confirmed they are in "very early stage discussions"
with Wimbledon about a possible merger of the two clubs.
The
talks began after QPR were put into administration with debts of around
�8m, while Wimbledon have been searching for a permanent home for
several years.
The announcement came after a report in this
morning's Sun. The article claimed that the proposed new team will be
coached by Dons boss Terry Burton and will play its home games at Loftus
Road.
However, a spokesperson for Loftus Road plc, the owners of QPR, was at pains to state that a final decision has yet to be made.
"Our
initial view is that, in the current financial environment for football
outside the Premier League, the idea could have merit and may be worth
exploring further," he explained.
"But we must emphasise that it
is still very early days and no firm agreement whatsoever has been
reached. The talks with Wimbledon will only continue if there is general
approval from our supporter base."
Wimbledon chairman Charles Koppel also played down the reports.
"No
agreement to merge Wimbledon with QPR has been reached," he insisted.
"While discussions regarding the idea of a possible merger have taken
place, we realise that no agreement could ever be reached without
consulting our supporters first.
"If the fans felt that this was not the best thing, we would re-evaluate and move along a different route."
Unsurprisingly, supporters have already opposed the mooted merger.
Libby
Magrill, spokeswoman for QPR 1st, the Queens Park Rangers Supporters
Trust, said: "Historically, QPR fans will not support a merger with any
other Football League club.
"Proposed mergers with Brentford in
1967 and Fulham in 1987 were successfully opposed by the fans, and any
move to merge QPR with Wimbledon this year, or at any stage in the
future, will be opposed by every possible means.
"QPR fans will fight to retain the identity of our club. We know that Wimbledon fans will do the same."
Wimbledon
fans also expressed their opposition to the proposal, promising to
protest at a meeting between the club and supporters' organisations
later this week.
The Wimbledon Independent Supporters'
Association declared that they "unequivocally oppose the merger of two
separate identities, families, supporters and histories" and added: "At
our forthcoming meeting on Sunday with chairman Charles Koppel prior to
the final game of the season, we shall be discussing and exploring the
way to go forward.
"In addition, we shall be making clear to the
owners of Wimbledon Football Club our desire for our own stadium and
retained identity.
"We urge the vigilance of Wimbledon and QPR supporters during this time and ask that you make your voices heard far and wide."
Meanwhile,
speculation that a third London club, Brentford, could also become
involved was dismissed by chairman Ron Noades, who had been linked with a
rival bid.
Noades told the Evening Standard: "We are not interested in any merger with or takeover of QPR.
"We
were in talks with QPR about a possible ground share at Loftus Road but
those cannot proceed until the club is out of administration.
"In the meantime, our own talks about a new ground for Brentford in the borough of Hounslow are progressing well.
"If
QPR and Wimbledon merge we would be interested to talk to them about a
possible ground share if we do manage to move to a new home ourselves."
It
has also been reported that an unidentified City-based consortium are
preparing a �12m bid to buy QPR outright and keep the club's identity.
Their
bid is for the rugby and football wings of Loftus Road plc and would
involve QPR and Wasps sharing Rangers' Acton training ground http://www.guardian.co.uk/football/2001/may/03/newsstory.sport8
Guardian
QPR-Dons merger 'to be dead within 48 hours'
Sean Ingle guardian.co.uk, Friday 4 May 2001
proposed
merger between Wimbledon and Queens Park Rangers is likely be called
off within the next 48 hours after opposition from supporters groups.
"The
merger isn't going to happen," QPR 1st spokesperson Libby Magrill told
Guardian Unlimited today. "We met with QPR chairman Chris Wright
yesterday, and although he wasn't that keen on the idea anymore anyway,
we helped to persuade him that it was an awful plan."
"QPR had
planned to send a questionnaire about the merger to supporters, but I
don't think they are going to do it anymore," she added. "What's the
point? They know everyone is dead against the plan."
"The
Wimbledon Supporters Association will meet with their chairman Charles
Koppel on Sunday, but by then I think the deal be dead."
This is Local London
Qpr Fans Scupper Plan To Merge With Wimbledon Wednesday 9th May 2001
Fan power has killed off suggestions of a merger between Queens Park Rangers and Wimbledon football clubs.
On
Thursday last week, QPR's board said in a statement: "It is true that
we are in very early stage discussions with Wimbledon Football Club
about a possible merger." But outraged QPR fans immediately set about
scuppering the idea.
Libby Magrill, spokeswoman for QPR 1st, the
Queens Park Rangers Supporters Trust, said the group would vigorously
oppose any merger between QPR and Wimbledon. "Historically, QPR fans
will not support a merger with any other Football League club. Proposed
mergers with Brentford in 1967 and Fulham in 1987 were successfully
opposed by the fans."
Only three days later, the Loftus
Road-based club reversed its intentions: "After serious consideration
and talks with supporters, the boards of Loftus Road and Queens Park
Rangers have decided not to take discussions with Wimbledon Football
Club regarding a possible merger any further."
The merger was
seen to have financial merit because it would have pooled the resources
of two clubs suffering serious financial problems. QPR are in
administration with debts of about �8 million and Wimbledon have no home
ground of their own.
There was also confusion about which
division a merged club would play in. Currently Wimbledon are in
Division One and QPR, following this season's relegation, will start
next season in Division Two.
Both QPR and the Wasps Rugby team
are owned by Loftus Road plc, whose chairman is Chris Wright, the
multi-millionaire founder of the Chrysalis media empire. Mr Wright wants
to sell his controlling interest in QPR, but keep the Wasps, ending the
link between the two organisations.
There will be a special
meeting of Loftus Road on May 16 to debate Mr Wright's offer to buy
Wasps.Fan power has killed off suggestions of a merger between Queens
Park Rangers and Wimbledon football clubs.
On Thursday last week,
QPR's board said in a statement: "It is true that we are in very early
stage discussions with Wimbledon Football Club about a possible merger."
But outraged QPR fans immediately set about scuppering the idea.
Libby
Magrill, spokeswoman for QPR 1st, the Queens Park Rangers Supporters
Trust, said the group would vigorously oppose any merger between QPR and
Wimbledon. "Historically, QPR fans will not support a merger with any
other Football League club. Proposed mergers with Brentford in 1967 and
Fulham in 1987 were successfully opposed by the fans."
Only three
days later, the Loftus Road-based club reversed its intentions: "After
serious consideration and talks with supporters, the boards of Loftus
Road and Queens Park Rangers have decided not to take discussions with
Wimbledon Football Club regarding a possible merger any further."
The
merger was seen to have financial merit because it would have pooled
the resources of two clubs suffering serious financial problems. QPR are
in administration with debts of about �8 million and Wimbledon have no
home ground of their own.
There was also confusion about which
division a merged club would play in. Currently Wimbledon are in
Division One and QPR, following this season's relegation, will start
next season in Division Two.
Both QPR and the Wasps Rugby team
are owned by Loftus Road plc, whose chairman is Chris Wright, the
multi-millionaire founder of the Chrysalis media empire. Mr Wright wants
to sell his controlling interest in QPR, but keep the Wasps, ending the
link between the two organisations.
There will be a special meeting of Loftus Road on May 16 to debate Mr Wright's offer to buy Wasps.
By.Ted Bridges
|