-
Plenderleith: MLS Beats the English Style
By Ian Plenderleith
USSoccerPlayers (April 19, 2007) -- At what level could Major League Soccer teams compete in England? The lower Premier League? The second or third division?
Having grown up in England, but lived in the US for almost a decade, it's a question I'm often asked, but now dread to hear. It's almost like asking how the Lakers would fare against the Red Sox.
Having just spent a short time in the UK, however, the inclination to compare the soccer in MLS with what I witnessed at three professional games in England has become impossible to resist. But it's not the perceived difference in standard that interests me. It's the difference in style.
In terms of atmosphere, tradition, passion and wit, attending a game in England, in the lower leagues at least, continues to be a more exciting and enjoyable game-day experience than it is in most MLS stadiums. But these established staples can not paper over the fact that many of these games are horrible to watch.
On March 31, I was at Queens Park Rangers versus West Bromwich Albion, in "The Championship" (that is, division two). QPR were just above the relegation zone, while West Brom were looking to enter the playoffs, with hopes of regaining the Premier League spot they lost last season. So with both teams having something to play for, I was expecting a reasonably good game for my $44 (the cheapest ticket, just three rows up from the touchline).
The first half yielded no goals, and little action, with the two sides hammering long balls forward, which were either dealt with easily by the central defenders, or bounced into touch. It may have been the jetlag, or it may have been the tactics, but I briefly fell asleep in a football stadium for the first time in my life. At halftime I declared to my two friends it was the worst half of soccer I'd ever seen, and they looked surprised. Maybe they're used to it.
With both sides needing points, perhaps halftime would see a change in approach. Indeed, West Brom tried the revolutionary doctrine of passing the ball along the ground, and scored. Rangers responded with more long balls and high crosses. They brought on striker Dexter Blackstock, who responded by heading a cross home with his first touch. See, if you just bang the ball in enough times, eventually someone will get on the end of one. This was broadly the philosophy of former England manager Graham Taylor, who found that what worked well at club level, didn't pan out in the international game.
Encouraged by a suddenly animated crowd, QPR then won a penalty, which they missed. Albion, continuing to attempt some fluent football through their midfielders Jason Koumas and Jonathan Greening, scored a deserved, and nicely worked, game-winner with four minutes to go. QPR fans, however, felt they'd been desperately unlucky -- if only we'd scored that penalty, we might have won! They applauded their team generously at the end. Way too generously, in my view, but then I'm not a QPR fan. And I appreciate that it was preferable to booing them off the pitch. They did, after all, run and run and run.
But what about the technique? The game was extremely fast, and the players so fit that they barely had the time or the space to do anything with the ball other than hurriedly whack it upfield. Footballing philosophies have not kept pace with advances in body training and diet. And such is the financial pressure on clubs nowadays, that results have become way more important than entertainment. While the same top four teams, fat on Champions League and other revenues, dominate the top positions in the Premier League season after season, the rest of the professional sphere struggles just to keep them within sight, both financially and on the field.
A week later I had the misfortune to see a game two tiers lower -- Lincoln City against Stockport County in "League 2" (that is, fourth division, at a slightly less extortionate $34). Even with each side having a player red-carded early on (a tall centerback and a tall center forward, giving me false hope that space would open up, and high balls would be abandoned), it was the same formula as the week before.
Lincoln has a small, skilful striker called Jamie Forrester, who spent the whole game, until he was substituted, trying to reach balls aimed over his head. The much taller defender behind him won the ball every single time. His replacement, a young loan player called Junior Mendes, showed some nice skill on the ball right after coming on, and was then clattered by a Stockport defender for his troubles. The defender was only cautioned, while Mendes limped around ineffectively for the rest of the game. Score: 0-0.
Now, I realize I might have been unlucky in seeing two poor games (and a third two days later, but I'll spare you the details), and I'm not about to deny that there are matches up and down England every week with variant thrill levels. But if you've watched coverage of non-Premier League games on Setanta Sports, you'll know that the tedious, long ball game is far from an unusual event in soccer's self-appointed home. Frankly, I'd choose MLS ahead of this nihilistic dross any day of the week.
It astounds me that so many US-based fans still revere English soccer and turn their noses up at MLS as a somehow inferior product. It's not that I necessarily believe that, kick for kick, MLS offers a better standard of play compared with most English teams. But at least it's here, and either in your city or coming to a city near you (or the suburb of a city near you). Instead of moaning about it without watching it, get down to the stadium and moan about it there. At least you'll be making some noise.
I swooned at Manchester United's performance against Roma on TV last week as much as the next armchair fan, but Manchester United are no longer what English soccer is about (even if I saw couple of Stockport players encouragingly, but clumsily, try to execute Cristiano Ronaldo-style stepovers). For every nine-man passing move at Old Trafford, there are a thousand wasted punts at Loftus Road, Sincil Bank and all the other grounds of the country's four pro divisions.
So returning to MLS, and all the problems it still encounters on a weekly basis in providing a spectacle that will attract fans to its grounds, it's at least nice, in general, to see teams whose goalkeepers mostly roll the ball out on the ground, and who try to build play from the back with the old twin virtues of pass and move.
As West Brom found, patience can pay off.
Ian Plenderleith is MLS Editor of USSoccerPlayers.com. Contact him at: iplenderleith@usnstpa.com Article
About the Author - Bio
Welcome to QPR REPORT - A completely unofficial and unaffiliated fan site focusing on G-d's Chosen Team, Queen's Park Rangers (QPR) FC. (Visit also QPR Report Messageboard and Follow on Twitter.) QPR Report accepts no sponsorship, advertising or financial contributions. In 2008, QPR Report was named as one of the top two blogs in the Football League
QPR Report Twitter Feed
Thursday, April 19, 2007
Blog Archive
-
▼
2007
(1727)
-
▼
April
(101)
- Coming Changes at Loftus Road
- Ex-QPR's Richard Graham Released By Barnet
- Former QPR Dean Parrett Played in England's Wemble...
- Former QPR Player Appointed Premiership Manager
- Stoke Looking at QPR: Want More Tickets
- QPR's Jake Cole Speaking About His Hopes
- How Ex-QPR Players Did Yesterday
- QPR Lose to Wolves - Reports & Comments
- Witney United Chairman Comments Re QPR
- Nostalgia: Three Years Since Chairman Paladini Bou...
- Ex-QPR - Ian Holloway on Coach Gary Penrice Expand...
- QPR Versus Wolves
- QPR Fined Over January Luton "Brawl"
- Simon Royce Apparently NOT Being Recalled from Gil...
- QPR Fan Forum Held with Chairman Paladini, Manager...
- Managerial Longevity: QPR'sJohn Gregory Already 6...
- One Year Ago: Paladini Spoke...Players Released......
- QPR Fan Forum Tonight...Recalling The Last Fan Forum
- QPR Goalie Lee Camp Again Goes Back to Derby!
- Nostalgia: Three Years Ago today, Gianni Paladini ...
- Nostalgia 1: QPR's Final Game Team Lineups over Pa...
- Gregory and Paladini and Ainsworth on QPR and Fort...
- John Gregory Stays on as QPR Manager
- John Gregory's Record at QPR: 46 Points from 36 Ga...
- QPR Captain Bignot Highly Praises Gregory....Addit...
- No Lee Cook in PFA Championship Team of the Year
- QPR's Defeat of Cardiff: Additional Reports & Comm...
- Les Ferdinand Profile - His Love For Newcastle, Hi...
- How Various Ex-QPR's Did Yesterday
- QPR's Manager John Gregory's Post Match Comments
- QPR Beat Cardiff and Guarantee Championship Footba...
- Cardiff vs QPR - Cardiff Views & Preparations
- Ex-QPR's Clarke Carlisle on Problems Overcome
- Flashback Six Years: QPR Relegated
- Cardiff Preview of QPR Game
- American-Based Soccer Writer Looks at QPR and Comp...
- Royce Joins Gillingham
- QPR's Season Tickets Prices & Declining Attendances
- Gone-Back-to-Southampton Idiakez Talks re QPR and ...
- This Weekend's Crucial Games
- Half-a-Year Since QPR "Parted Company With" Gary W...
- Ex-QPR Player & Manager Trevor Francis Birthday
- Mail "Gossip" - Spurs Looking at Cook
- QPR Announce Season Ticket Price Reduction for Nex...
- Almost Five Years Since QPR's ABC Loan, Exit Admin...
- Ex-QPR's Dean Parrett in England U-16 Squad to Pla...
- QPR Goalie Paul Jones Turns 40
- Gregory: No Player Contracts Till Status Determine...
- Hopefully Good News for QPR re Lee Camp: Derby's B...
- QPR Officially Announce Witney Friendly is Cancelled
- Ex-QPR Adam Miller, Staying at Stevenage
- Hammanless Cardiff Visit Loftus Road
- The "History" of QPR's Non-Game vs Witney United
- Idiakez Returns to Southampton
- Ex-QPR's Danny Dichio Moves to North America, MLS ...
- QPR vs Sunderland - Additional Reports & Comments
- Tony Roberts on His Hoped-For Return to League Foo...
- Championship Relegation Strugglers: Final Fixtures
- Championship Relegation: Past Seasons Points Total...
- Coleman to Replace Gregory?
- How "QPR Players" Not at QPR Did Yesterday: Dohert...
- QPR's Sunderland Defeat - Mangerial Comments & Mat...
- Four Years Ago: QPR's Troubles ...One Year Ago: Wa...
- Oops at Swindon re Takeover Disclosure
- Sunderland vs QPR Previews
- Ex-QPR's Peter Crouch Explains Supported QPR NOT C...
- Witney United Denounce QPR Chairman, Gianni Paladini
- Ex-QPR's Ian Evatt Doing Great at Blackpool
- QPR's Young Star, Shabbaz Baidoo Celebrates a Birt...
- QPR NOT Playing Witney United Friendly
- Report of Fans Consultative Group Meeting with The...
- Club Announces Fan Forum...Reminder of Last Fan Forum
- QPR's Zesh Rehman on being good Enough For Premier...
- QPR Trailing in the "Coca Cola 'Buy A Player' Leag...
- Ainsworth Writes about his Injury and on QPR's Sur...
- QPR Snippets: Cole Suspended...Chairman's Rib...Ga...
- Gregory on Staying Up...Cullip on Gregory...Moore ...
- Witney vs QPR April 30?
- Couple of Ex-QPR Defenders' Birthdays
- Six Months Ago II: The Fan Forum with Paladini & G...
- Six Months Ago I: Tracy Stent's Comprehensive Tria...
- QPR's Crucial Luton Victory - Further Reports
- Gallen's Sciatic Problem: Returned
- Gareth Ainsworth Breaks Leg
- QPR SCRAPE a Victory Over Luton
- Additional Reports of QPR's Win in Coventry
- QPR's Coventry Victory:Reports & Comments Compilation
- Billy Bonds on Nigel Quashie as a QPR Youth Player
- The Final Month...The Final Game
- Inigo Idiakez QPR Loan Extended
- Son of QPR Holdings Chairman' Joins Racing Lineup
- Gregory Critiques His Inherited Players...Stewart ...
- Six Months Since Backroom Departures & Arrivals
- Gregory Critical of Pre-Season Preparations & Look...
- QPR's Vital Victory - Compilation of Reports & Com...
- Victory for Queens Park Rangers over Preston
- Twenty-Five Years Ago Today: QPR Reach Wembley For...
- QPR's Press/Directors Stewards "Departing"
- QPR Player Makes Championship "Team of The Week"
- QPR's WBA Loss - Further Reports and Comments
-
▼
April
(101)